Scott McCloud at Agnes Scott College September 16, 2008

scott mccloud’s talk at graphic 2011

Scott McCloud at Agnes Scott College September 16, 2008The Graphic Storytelling Festival made a bunch of headlines in the last week or so because of the Sydney Telegraph scaring off Robert Crumb. (Fuck You Sydney Telegraph.) But Crumb wasn’t the only draw. Scott McCloud made te intercontinental trek to give a talk called Understanding Comics, and I bought tickets for myself and Holly.

I figured this would be a good event for her, because she’s been reading a few more comics recently (Persepolis and the first Absolute volume of Sandman), but the only person blathering at her about how significant and important they are is me. And I get very scattered and distracted and haven’t been doing this since 1993. So having so good a blatherer about comics as Scott McCloud explaining the stuff I’m a lukewarm (but passionate) rehasher of, sounded perfect.

His presentation was less than an hour but packed with stuff about visual communication and its uses in education and the way we as humans live. He demonstrated the Grimace project which uses his facial expression diagrams from Making Comics. He showed sketches of the semiotics of comics and talked about how tragic it is that in school we’re taught about all the different ways writing can be used, but we restrict drawing to self-expression only, since it can do all sorts of amazing stuff. He said recently he was at a “second annual” Comics in Medicine convention, which was awesome and spoke to the educational nature of comics. He stressed how comics don’t reduce information, but concentrate it into easily remembered forms, like mnemonic devices.

McCloud showed loads of slides, but they were done really well in a way that was not a bunch of boring bulleted lists. He was using Keynote, not Prezi or anything fancy, just using the tools in a better way (lots of slides, little text) which helped highlight his points about visual communication, and how we should be approaching them as “tools of empowerment.”

That tied in well to his talking about libraries. In the Q&A I asked if he had any recommendations for libraries in dealing with comics. He had a few comments:

  • Libraries should put the comics-knowledgeable staff in charge of them, that that domain knowledge is really important to making a good comics section. Note that well, future employers of mine. This is what I was made to do.
  • Libraries just have to look at the circulation numbers to see if comics are a good idea. He gave the example of a great library in Alaska whose circulation numbers jumped by something like 800% when they committed to comics.
  • To work with comics in libraries we have to bypass the “at least they’re reading something” mentality. That wasn’t a terrible hook in years gone by, but treating comics as complex literature with many different layers, is better for comics as we go forward. Not everything is Watchmen, but in the prose section it’s not like libraries only have War & Peace either.

He also had some comments about creating better classification systems for comics in libraries. In his opinion people think in terms of form first, so it still makes sense to shelve the nonfiction Graphic Novels together rather than interfile them with the rest of the books on a subject. Oh! He also called graphic novels “a specific type, format and approach to comics,” which I appreciated. I’m one of those people who resists calling comics graphic novels just to confer some legitimacy on them through linguistic sleight-of-hand, so this fits my worldview and expands it a bit. Which is what you want out of a talk, right? That and an enthusiastic reading of his “really dumb” comic about MonkeyForces fighting zombies of MonkeyTown in an escalating to kaiju battle epic. (He said he was inspired to do something more performance-like by being in the Sydney Opera House.)

After it was over, Holly said she almost wished she was teaching so she could use some of that theory in her educational repertoire. It was a really good afternoon.

4 thoughts on “scott mccloud’s talk at graphic 2011

  1. I was at the talk, and I thought this was an interesting question. I wasn’t aware that there was an issue with comics in libraries – as a daughter of librarians, I’ve actually seen the catalogues that the acquisitions department uses to order new graphic novels in. My only complaint is that they tend to order whatever volumes of a series they happen to see in the catalogue – say Volumes 15, 16 and 17 of an extended series – which drives me nuts!

    Perhaps I just happen to live near a particularly good library system – but then I’m biased! I like to think that my impeccable taste in reading materials has had some vicarious influence 😉 And you don’t have to have inside contacts like I do, most libraries allow patrons to suggest new titles they’d like to see on shelves.

    • Oh man, I’ve worked in libraries for a few years and the grabbing whatever numbers of a series bugs the hell out of me too. We used to have to hunt across twenty branches to get things remotely close to being in order for a patron looking to read a series, especially when it came to manga. Not the best way of doing things at all.

    • The peril of taking notes in a dark theatre is their later illegibility, but I don’t think I even attempted to write that down. I cannot remember for the life of me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s